WE'VE MOVED!

WE'VE MOVED!
Find All New Content at TheMatinee.ca

Sunday, October 3, 2010

Review: THE SOCIAL NETWORK * * * 1/2

A glance at my Facebook page tells me that I have a couple hundred people listed as my friends. I can tell you without hesitation that I do not interact with this many people in my life. Not even close.

But there they all are...framed in little boxes, smiling back at me under a pale blue label that confirms them as "Friends". How did this virtual oxymoron happen?

Set in 2004, THE SOCIAL NETWORK is told by way of two separate legal depositions intercut with the events those depositions are discussing. At the centre of it all is Mark Zuckerberg (Jesse Eisenberg), a Harvard student who creates a website one night. Its inspiration is one part anger, one part ambition, and three parts drunken restlessness. It proves to be a popular site - so popular in fact that it crashes Harvard's server.

The website was done for a lark, but it gets the attention at some members of a Harvard Final Club that he desperately wants to be a part of. The Final Clubs you see, come with a certain social status...something Zuckerberg can't seem to achieve on his own. When three members of The Final Club approach him to help them create their site, Zuckerberg gets hit with an even better idea. He comes up with a site that Harvard students will be able to interact with each other online, but still keep their privacy intact since it will all be by invitation only.

With his closest friends in tow, including Eduardo Saverin (Andrew Garfield) who puts up the money needed for R&D, Zuckerberg launches a site called "The Facebook". The whole thing becomes pretty popular, but raises the ire of the gang at The Final Club since they feel he ripped off the idea they tasked him with developing.

Zuckerberg continues to duck their ever-escalating threats, focusing instead on growing The Facebook into something bigger. As it expands to other schools, he gets the attention of Napster founder Sean Parker (Justin Timberlake). Parker likes the look of what they have, and agrees with Eduardo that there is money to be made with the project. However, he also understands that monetizing such a concept will have to be done delicately, lest all the fun get sucked out of it.

Three radically different personalities, the threat of legal action, a potentially world-changing idea. What could go wrong?

Everybody involved with this film has brought their A-Game. Eisenberg and Timberlake show us a side of themselves that we haven't seen yet, and Garfield continues an unforeseen run of great acting in a part that makes him this story's moral compass. While it can be overbearing at times, the entire story is made a tad more unsettling by an off-centre score by Trent Reznor, which compliments David Fincher's calculated direction perfectly. Fincher has taken a story that is little more than straight dialogue, given it a rhythm all its own, and turned what seemed on paper to be a pretty slight concept into a very captivating film.

One does have to wonder just how much of this story is true (The Erica Albrecht character for instance, was completely made up). That's the speedbump for this film on its drive to cinematic success: since we're talking about events that happened just six years ago, one has to wonder if filmmakers rushed this story in the race to tell it first. That aside, one has to admire the biggest irony of this entire story: a tool that is supposed to bring us together, allow us to have fun, and socially interact is created by a character who usually sits alone, never seems to be having any fun, and couldn't be more socially awkward.

When we spoke about the film, fellow blogger Sebastian Gutierrez zeroed in on a moment that encapsulates everything this story is about. A character sits alone in an empty room...makes a friend request on Facebook...and continually refreshes the page to see if the request is accepted. In reality, one has to wonder "what next?" Will he start sending messages to this person...rekindle a friendship...go out for a drink? Probably not. He is ceaselessly refreshing his browser to see if they will in fact be 'Facebook Friends' - a life he can keep tabs on, get an update at a glance, and maybe drop the odd comment on every once in a while. Just how social is that?

Thats what makes the story of THE SOCIAL NETWORK so interesting, is the fact that what these socially awkward/morally compromised college kids perhaps irreversibly changed our world because they were bored and looking for kicks one drunken Tuesday night. This tool that a huge percentage of the world uses gets tweaked to include a person's relationship status, because someone out there was too chicken-shit to walk up and actually ask another person about their relationship status. We have entered an age in which we all interact virtually, because a one guy who happened to have an idea wasn't that hot at interacting socially.

But it's not just him is it? So many of us these days have forsaken face time and picking up a phone in favour of communicating via text and sending brief instant messages. When Mark has his blow-out with Erica at the beginning of the film, he doesn't have the guts to tell her what he really thinks...but he has no qualms with publishing it for the whole wide world to read.

I don't want to sound like the old cotcher bitching about what technology has done to our lives (that'd actually seem pretty hypocritical), but after seeing a movie like THE SOCIAL NETWORK, one can't help but look at what these characters created...how it has affected our lives...and wonder if we are in fact better off?

What did you think? Please leave comments with your thoughts and reactions to THE SOCIAL NETWORK.

23 comments:

simoncolumb said...

im not reading this post. i CANNOT wiat for this movie. i wasn't fussed initially but since the hype, the talk of people who sat it early... and ultimately the soundtrack by reznor. i cannot wait. it will be immense!

Simon

Laura said...

I'm so surprised by all the love this film is getting. Granted, I haven't seen it yet. It's just that the trailer was so damned mediocre I thought nothing would come of this film. I had no desire to see it (and I love David Fincher). I still have no desire to see it. However, now I have to just to make an informed decision on what looks to be one of the best reviewed films of the year. lol.

mrtsblog said...

Like others I wasn't that keen to see this based simply on the concept but have since been seduced by rave reviews and talk of a quality score with snapshots of it in the trailer. It does look like Fincher has directed some interesting young actors in this and as you say the whole phenomenon of Facebook and the way it has changed social interaction, perhaps for the worse by offering cowardly, un-social ways out, is ethically fascinating. Great post as always, will let you know what I think when it comes out here

Simon said...

How I love this movie. Fincher really knows how to make a biopic without the sentimental bullshit.

Hal said...

"That aside, one has to admire the biggest irony of this entire story: a tool that is supposed to bring us together, allow us to have fun, and socially interact is created by a character who usually sits alone, never seems to be having any fun, and couldn't be more socially awkward."

Couldn't have said it better myself.

The Mad Hatter said...

@ Simon... No hard feelings, I don't read most reviews before watching/reviewing a film (which right now means I have a *lot* of SOCIAL NETWORK reviews to go through!).

Just c'mon back and leave a comment once you do see it.

@ Laura... Interesting that you mention the trailer since that was the first thing that drew me to this film (on paper it seemed like a dumb idea). It's solid, but I don't buy the whole "Best Film of The Year" buzz.

@ Mr T... Interesting that all the positive reviews have caught your attention as there have been a lot of movies where I had my expectations tweaked from so many rave reviews (for more on that, come back next Monday for the next episode of The Matineecast).

@ Simon... There was a bit of sentimental bullshit on the go, but you're right - Fincher's the man.

@ Hal... Many thanks. Now hopefully I'll get to read your review sometime soon!

GoodOldParanoia said...

Roger Ebert said '[...] To conceive of Facebook, Zuckerberg needed to know almost nothing about relationships or human nature (and apparently he didn't). What he needed was the ability to intuit a way to involve the human race in the Kevin Bacon Game.' and that's exactly the game we've been dragged into with this whole social-networking thing. Anyways, I love David Fincher (even though I didn't like Benjamin Button nor Zodiac at all...) and -despite of what Laura said- I dig the trailer. Sorkin + Fincher = :)

The Mad Hatter said...

@ Paranoia... (Nice to hear from you again!) I love Ebert's reviews, so even though I didn't read his before writing this, it's probably no fluke that I gravitate towards the same themes.

Not to get off on a tangent, but I actually love ZODIAC...and even like BEN BUTTON much more than I did on first watch.

GoodOldParanoia said...

I've subscribed to your rss so I don't miss your posts! The thing is I'm usually super-busy so I cannot comment on every post I read but I'll try to do so from now on :) Aaaaaand I think I'll rent Benjamin Button again if you tell me you liked it better the second time you watch it ;)

Fitz said...

This is one I'm going to see again in theatres. Really loved it.

The Mad Hatter said...

@ Paranoia... Such dedication. Again - thanks for keeping up with my babblings.

BUTTON was an odd instance, because I grabbed the Criterion dvd of it on a whim when I found it on sale. Going through all the features - especially Fincher's commentary - gave me more of an appreciation for the story.

I think when I saw it the first time, I was a victim of too much hype.

@ Fitz... I'll catch it again eventually, but there were films I loved more that I'm gonna doubleback on first.

Fletch said...

"He is ceaselessly refreshing his browser to see if they will in fact be 'Facebook Friends' - a life he can keep tabs on, get an update at a glance, and maybe drop the odd comment on every once in a while."

The thing that gets me about this is that - hello, the guy's the king of the site! He could go into the back end and make her friends with him whether she wanted to or not!

But that wouldn't be very dramatic, would it? Aside from the privacy issues. But still...

The Mad Hatter said...

@ Fletch... I think it's supposed to be a glimmer of sympathy for the Zuckerberg character. Yes he can easily hack her account (sidebar: If she knew he was behind the whole site, why would she sign up?) the same way he could easily knock on her door and apologize...but he's wired so incorrectly, that this is his best idea.

M. Carter @ the Movies said...

I've seen this but haven't gotten around to reviewing it yet...

I absolutely loved the film (not surprising, as I love David Fincher. Like a lot of viewers I wondered if he could make this film as intelligent and creepy as some of his others. And I was shocked that even though it's about Facebook and Zuckerburg, "Social Network" is every inch a David Fincher film. It's dark and unsettling and dramatic, and Andrew Garfield gives what has to be THE breakout performance of 2010. Great stuff.

The Mad Hatter said...

@ Meredith... Looking forward to reading your post when it does go up.

Yeah, I gotta hand it to David Fincher, on papaer this sounded like a pretty lame idea - kudos to him for infusing it with the human drama and style his films are becoming known for.

Might have to see this film one more time before it leaves theatres.

CMrok93 said...

Totally blown away by the fact, that a film about Facebook directed by David Fincher, can be a big-time Oscar contender. Loved it almost from start to finish, hope it gets awards come Oscar time. Nice post, check out my review when you can!

Anonymous said...

I don't want to sound like the old cotcher bitching about what technology has done to our lives- thats exactly what you sound like. that was a great movie which focused on issues and events of facebook. maybe you should watch and pay attention to the hardwork, dedication and issues those students went thru to create the one website that the whole world use daily.

The Mad Hatter said...

@ Anon... Not too sure why you think I need to further watch and pay more attention to the movie I've quite clearly stated I liked.

Joel Burman said...

Actually I'm with Fletch. The correct ending would have been for him to violate her profile by accessing it through his admin status.

The Mad Hatter said...

@ Joel... Of course that scene would have to be accompanied by the The Imperial March theme music from STAR WARS.

Joel Burman said...

That might be a bit over the top. I actually felt that the movie shoud have ended like this instead of the waiting for approaal thing.

Mostly because I think that kind of action from him would be more expected rather than yet again trying for her attention which obviously wont work.

Claire said...

Hi Hatter, I've finally got round to looking at your blog (and I’ll look at your TIFF posts soon) though I must admit I came looking tonight because I wanted to know what you thought of 'The Social Network'.

I must admit, I haven't seen it and as its been doing so well at the recent award ceremonies, I wanted to know what you think.

When I saw the trailer I just wasn't interested. I'm part of the Facebook generation; I have a profile. Perhaps I'm ignorant for not wanting to find out the 'story' behind its creation.

You're spot on when you wrote: "perhaps irreversibly changed our world." I completely agree with you. I'm annoyed with myself that to pass the time during my lunch break at work I have a look at Facebook. Like you say about having a couple hundred friends, I have about 400 though I don't actually want to chat with all 400 of them. I ring or visit the ones I do.

Now, after all that rambling, do you think its worth a watch? I like a lot of Fincher’s films and most of the time I like Jesse Eisenberg…

Claire

The Mad Hatter said...

@ Claire... Just bought it on Blu-ray last week actually, and while I don't think that it's the best film of the year (like all the critics and award bodies do), I do think it's a solid film and will be just fine with it being the film dubbed 'Top of The Class 2010'.

Definitely check it out - it's more a movie about the launch of an idea, and all the ambition and backstabbing that comes with it. basically, it's more than just "The Facebook Movie"