
How long are we supposed to stand back and do nothing? How long are we supposed to pull or drapes shut, and pretend that things we know are wrong just aren't happening in our backyard? Is it possible just to keep your head down and hope it all goes away...or will we eventually have to get our hands dirty when trouble comes knocking.
If HARRY BROWN is to believed, it's impossible to stay above the fray...and sometimes even the unlikeliest of people will get dragged into the fracas.
Harry Brown (Michael Caine) lives on a council estate in south London. It's a shitty neighbourhood, and a place where reckless young thugs have made innocent people afraid of setting foot out their front door. However, Harry has managed so far - mostly by sticking to his routine, and ignoring what's happening outside of his own front door.
However, one of Harry's only friends isn't so ambivalent. Leonard (David Bradley) has been harassed endlessly, and now conceals a bayonet on his person for protection should push come to shove with the young thugs. Harry begs him not to take matters into his own hands, and instead to go to the police. Unfortunately that very night, Leonard gets into an altercation with the punks which costs him his life.
The next morning, when detective Frampton (Emily Mortimer) comes knocking to tell harry the bad news, Harry is very sad for about sixty seconds, then he lashes out at the cops for not being able to do their job. It's here that Harry seems to have seen enough. He decides to take it upon himself to avenge his murdered friend, and try to restore some order to the slum his neighbourhood has become.
HARRY BROWN really all boils down to Michael Caine and his ability to create such a distinct character. Harry is a man of few words, but we can see in his routines and his habits what sort of a meticulous man he is. He's not only the sort of man who does the same thing every day, but he's very particular in how he does it. This is to say that not only does every morning begin with a cup of tea and piece of toast...but that breakfast is immediately followed by sweeping the crumbs from the table and washing the dishes. So perhaps we shouldn't be so surprised when Harry finally takes matters into his own hands. But we are - making his decisions all the more unsettling.
Harry might have a lot of fight left in him, but he often moves around as though a badly masoned cobblestone will send him face-first into the sidewalk. Thus when he knocks on the thugs' door looking to get a handgun and put his plan in motion, we are filled with a sense of dread. So much so, that the only thing we can think of that will let him walk out alive, is the fact that his name gets top billing in the film.
Much to our surprise though, harry is as meticulous in his vengeance as he is in sweeping up crumbs and doing his dishes. Its this part of the character that makes Michael Caine's performance so amazing to watch. With his every expression and gesture, he embodies a man who has gone to great lengths to put distance between himself and his violent past as a soldier. He urges us all to trust the authorities to protect us, and the sadness in his eyes almost turns it into a plea. But when those very same authorities let him down, those pleading eyes turn scolding in a hurry.
Then, once Caine is finished scolding, he takes us on a boat ride down the darkened river. The story of HARRY BROWN gets grim in a hurry...continuing on where a story like GRAN TORINO would be wishing it a goodnight and good luck. Deeply unsettling, and stunning in its grittiness, HARRY BROWN wants to tell us about the violence that even the most seemingly passive person is capable of. This person might hold a desire to stay out of the fray...and this person might believe that they're a changed person. However, what this film understands, is that we all have that one particular nerve, that when pressed can bring out a side of ourselves we truly wanted to leave behind.
HARRY BROWN is ultimately a simple story elevated to an exceptional film through subtle direction, gloriously dreary tone, and a stellar performance. Having become accustomed to see Caine cast as the wise and docile elder statesman, it's a welcome sight to see him walk as a badass again. Such a badass in fact, that I'd wager he could take on every single one of The Expendables, come out with barely a scratch, and still make it home in time for tea.
What did you think? Feel free to leave comments with any thoughts or reactions on HARRY BROWN.
Wednesday, August 18, 2010
Review: HARRY BROWN * * * 1/2
Posted by
Ryan McNeil
at
8/18/2010 08:00:00 AM
Labels: 3.5 stars, drama, dvd, emily mortimer, michael caine, reviews
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)


14 comments:
I too liked this very much. I've seen some people questioning its underlying morality (does it promote violence as the answer?) but in all honesty, I think that is confusing fiction for fact. Having said that, considering how gritty and realistic Barber makes the film (the final scenes in particular look scarily familiar to the real-life Bradford race riots of a few years ago) you can understand how people fail to make that distinction. I thought it was something really original with, as you say, a great performance from Caine.
Caine's still got it!
It was good, and Caine is strong here, the only problem is that the violence doesn't quite support the themes and ideas the film was quite going for.
@ CMRok... OK, you have my attention. Elaborate.
It was alright. Revelled in it's own violence, I think.
@ FI... Strange that people are questioning the morality of this story, since it so very clearly amoral. Is there any debate that what Harry eventually does is a horrible idea? Oh well...any film that sparks debate is usually a good thing right?
And indeed - Caine is awesome. here's hoping more people check this out on dvd
@ Filmgeek... He sure does! He could teach Badass 101 after this role.
@ Simon... I don't know if it revelled per se, but it sure did enjoy taking us down a truly dreary path.
For me, "Harry Brown" is a case of a film that I respect immensely, but at the same time, I find it very tough to enjoy. I respect it mostly for Caine's performance, and the faithful, consistently bleak tone throughout.
The problem I have with the film is that there really isn't any positive emotion in it. On top of that, there is a great deal of realistic, horrendous violence. I don't think I can look back on my experience watching this film and say that I want to see it again.
I think that if the film tried to cover some new thematic ground (the "old guy vigilante" thriller is becoming a sub-genre of its own, then I would have gotten more out of it.
Sorry. Hated this film.
The whole thing is so ugly and repulsive and skinheaded. It's half retirement-home Death Wish and half socially relevant drama and ultimately the result is oppressive. For such flimsy material, it can't even have some fun.
On the positive side, It did have the great Emily Mortimer in it...
I had this on my To-See list and now I'm pumped even more. Missed it when it as in-and-out in the tehater here. Can't wait to see it. Nice review mad hatter!!!
I keep on passing up the chance to see it, but now I may just have to see what the fuss is about. I've read some very horrid pans, though.
@ Danny... I totally see that, but strangely I find myself drawn to bleak films sometimes...kinda makes me look at my life and say "Mighta had a bad day, but at least things aren't that bad".
@ Chase... Wow - that bad huh? I can see how it could turn people off, and certainly cannot argue with you. Still, despite its grim tone, I thought it was worth recommending. (Did you blog about it? I'd love to read your post)
@ Peter... I damned near missed it myself. It came out in early May when I was preoccupied with documentaries, and seemed to be gone in a blink. Thankfully Toronto has some swell rep cinemas that give you a second kick at the can with this sort of movie.
Luckily for you, it hits dvd in two weeks.
@ Andrew... I've heard it compared to GRAN TORINO. Not sure if that's good or bad for ya, but take it for what its worth.
I'd be hard-pressed to call it Death Wish bad. Death Wish bordered on racism, sexism and countless others isms I could name, but would prefer to ignore.
@ Fitz... Interesting. I get someone not liking something, but to compare it to something so extreme?
Oh well, as Chase says - he hated it.
Love your write-ups. Very thorough and insightful. This, I thought, was one of the better vigilante films released in recent years. It was nice to see Caine in a role worthy of his talent, as Nolan just likes to waste him in thankless roles. Caine is subtle here and efficient. I thought Mortimer could have had more depth, and I usually like her. But a good flick, certainly worth seeing!
Post a Comment