WE'VE MOVED!

WE'VE MOVED!
Find All New Content at TheMatinee.ca

Monday, June 28, 2010

Review: WINTER'S BONE * * * *


Sometimes we find ourselves in a tough spot - in a position where we find ourselves saying "I don't want to, but I will if I have to." Usually when this happens, it's because we're doing it for people we love...people who might not be able to take care of themselves. This is the crux of the dark tale of WINTER'S BONE.

Our story is set in The Ozarks, where 17-year-old Ree Dolly (Jennifer Lawrence) lives. Her father has left, and her mother is incapacitated. Ree is all alone trying to look after her young brother and sister and keep everybody's head above water. They have next to no money, even less food. They live the sort of life where you hang your laundry out to dry even in the dead of winter. Indeed, they have next to nothing, and they're about to lose a big portion of what they do have.

Their father - charged with cooking crank and out on bail - has slipped off the map. This sends a bondsman to the house calling on Ree, and he informs her that her father put his house up as his bond. If he can't be found within a week to appear before a judge, their meagre home and everything in it, will be seized.

This sends Ree on a quest through her gutter of a community, looking for her father. The problem is that everyone she talks to knows exactly what he was into (no stretch, since many of them are into it too), and they aren't talking. Not even her closest relative, her uncle "Teardrop" (John Hawkes) will help her.

Unfortunately, Ree isn't the sort of girl to take "no" for an answer. Thus she keeps asking questions, getting no answers, but getting a lot of threats. In the face of very palpable danger, she continues searching for what she believes is a very ugly truth. She and her family have very little...but there's no way she's losing what little they have left without a fight.


WINTER'S BONE is a slow walk through the valley of the shadow of death. We can tell that Ree doesn't really want to keep going...keep asking questions...keep pressing her luck. Thing is, she has to. She and her family have been left with as close to nothing as one family can get. It's unsettling to see her press the sort of people I wouldn't ask for a match from, but her lack of alternatives leaves her with little options.

Jennifer Lawrence carries this film, with precious little of the story happening without her there. She taps into a delicate mix of desperation, frustration, delicacy, and anger. She has taken over the role of matriarch in her family, and we can sense a reluctant pride in the way she tries to care for her siblings, and teach them to fend all at once.

In a particularly telling moment, she catches a glimpse of her neighbours with a bounty of fresh meat, and if her eyes could salivate, they would. Seconds later, her younger brother seems to express what she's thinking and suggests they go ask for a portion. Lawrence does an amazing about-face at this moment, and teaches her brother about asking and offering. It's subtle moments like this that really make the performance.

Ree's journey for truth has been called by some as "Hillbilly Noir". I like the term, since indeed all the hallmarks are there. The hero is a loser, the story is one of betrayal, and there are more than one ambivalent bystanders. the film isn't in black and white, but given the grim, dreary colour palette it damned well could be. It's noir! The only thing missing is a femme fatale...but in a town like this, I'm a little afraid to see their excuse for a femme fatale.

While this film was difficult to watch, it was fascinating as it takes a very particular breed of community and shows how even though they don't have much more than each other, they draw lines and decide for themselves who is worth helping and who is not. It's a sad state of affairs that I'd like to believe is complete fiction, but I fear isn't the case. An engaging, if upsetting film, and easily one of the best this year.

What did you think? Feel free to leave comments with any thoughts or reactions on WINTER'S BONE.

12 comments:

Univarn said...

I've heard nothing but the highest of praise for this movie. I really hope it finds its way to NC soon.

Aiden R. said...

Great review, man. I totally forgot about that awesome line from Ree, "Never ask for what should be offered." (or something like that). Loved this movie, too, haven't seen anything close to this good all year. Lawrence was great and so was John Hawkes as Teardrop - that guy needs more work. Also loved the dialogue, it's not often where you see so much weight given to such choice words. Man, I could go on, but the point is I completely agree. Best movie out there right now, but I still need to see Toy Story 3.

Alex said...

I LOVE this movie. I hope it wins every Oscar. And I hope Jennifer Lawrence is cast in every movie.

Bob Turnbull said...

Lawrence was terrific, wasn't she? I thought at the outset of the film that she was a bit too "pretty" for the lifestyle that she must've led in that environment, but due to the strength of her performance and the way she goes about her quest, all those concerns disappeared quite quickly. And the whole cast was excellent...

Interesting comparison to Noir. Certainly there are some thematic commonalities regarding doing what you have to do to survive and how you can't avoid your fate once you've decided how to live your life. It goes places that only some of the darkest Noirs really go too...

Fitz said...

This won't be anywhere near me for a while. I expect this to be every bit as good as your review.

Kaiderman said...

Another 4 star review? It's been a good month! I have heard nothing but the best about this film... too bad I can't find a screen showing it! Have you heard all the hub-bub Lawrence's sexy shoot for (what was it?) Esquire magazine?

The Mad Hatter said...

@ Univarn... Keep an eye out for it. It's pretty good in a SLING BLADE sort of way.

@ Aiden... Good point with the dialogue. The people Ree meets have so little to say to her, yet they really measure their words carefully and so so much with so littl. Making all the more unsettling!

@ Alex... Pardon me while I go search for your review. Here's hoping we've just watched another breakout performance.

@ Bob... I can't take much credit for the noir comparison, since it was Kurt who I first heard mention the term "Hillbilly Noir". Remind me to thank him for that tonight.

@ Fitz... Is there any use in asking your theatre manager to try and bring it in? Might not be up to him/her, but it might be worth an ask.

@ Kaiderman... Yeah, handing out another ace was surprising to me too, but I really couldn't find anything wrong with this movie. A lot of the smaller films we talked about during the podcast have been building up to this, and I'm really hoping people make a point to see it.

And yeah, I saw those Esquire photos...guess she wanted to show that she's not just a dour teen in a parka and hopes to parlay it into flashier parts.

Peter Eramo said...

Great review. It is playing in 2 theatres around here so I will certainly catch it when the proper mood hits me. Seems like a tough movie to watch, but I'm into that! Have only read good things here, yours included. Looks better than anything else playing right now...

Fitz said...

Well if I were in Reno right now that would work (manager is an extremely nice guy) but I'm away for the next three weeks.

Andrew: Encore Entertainment said...

I'm very anxious to see how I'll greet this one. Mostly positive reviews, and then some interesting negative ones.

Danny King said...

Surprisingly, this one didn't work for me. I'll let it digest a little longer before writing my review. but for now, I think the film is unsure of the message it wants to send - is it one of pervasive bleakness or subtle hope? Whichever one it is, I don't think the film is effective in communicating that. I also found the storyline to be very uninteresting.

The Mad Hatter said...

@ Peter... If you've already seen TOY STORY 3, then this is the only other great one out there. I always suggest that of you're worried about being bummed, track down a matinee showing of it so you can soak up some sunshine once the credits roll.

@ Fitz... It'll keep.

@ Andrew... It won't be for everyone, but do kwwp in mind that it took the top prize at Sundance this year...if that tells you anything.

@ Danny... If you're working on digesting it, perhaps I can persuade you to listen to The Creative Screenwriting Podcast. They did an episode a few weeks back of a Q&A with the director.

It's very insightful and may help guide your opinion.